
Ateneo School of Government dean Atty. Antonio Gabriel ‘Tony’ La Viña. (Photo from Alchetron)
With the impeachment court now convened to place Vice President “Inday” Sara Duterte-Carpio on trial, former Ateneo School of Government dean Atty. Antonio Gabriel “Tony” La Viña has expressed that it would be difficult to convict Duterte because it would require 16 affirmative votes from the 24 sitting senators.
However, La Viña noted that the evidence to be presented during the trial would be important, as it could “change minds” to favor a conviction.
He cited that President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr.’s role will become critically important, recalling previous cases wherein votes were swayed because of influence from Malacañan.
“The signs coming from President Marcos Jr. toward the possible votes are important,” the legal expert stated, while pointing out several cases currently being faced by some senators.
He gave as an example the case of impeached Chief Justice Renato Corona, who was convicted by the Senate impeachment court in 2012 for his failure to disclose to the public his statement of assets, liabilities, and net worth (SALN).
According to La Viña, since it was projected that there were initially just 12 to 14 votes in favor of convicting Corona, the situation prompted then President Benigno Simeon “Noynoy” Aquino III to “persuade” the senator-judges to convict the former chief justice.
“I think there is a chance to convict Sara, but it is politically challenging, unless there is vigilance on our part and, of course, pressure on the President to actually take steps,” he asserted.
To put pressure on the Marcos administration, he urged the public to consider its response to upcoming developments in the impeachment trial, especially toward a possible motion to dismiss that may be filed by the vice president.
“We need to react quickly that this is not acceptable,” he advised.
In addition, La Viña also disclosed that it might be fatal to the impeachment case if the official bank accounts of Sara Duterte are not presented.
“There are two obstacles: the impeachment court and the Supreme Court, because she would surely appeal to the Supreme Court,” he pointed out.
La Viña mentioned that the allegations about Vice President Duterte’s unexplained wealth and misuse of confidential funds are the most important ones, given her upcoming impeachment trial.
In a previous hearing by the House committee on justice regarding the impeachment complaints against the vice president, the Anti-Money Laundering Council told lawmakers that banks have flagged billions of pesos worth of transactions linked to Duterte and her husband, Manases “Mans” Carpio.
This includes 33 suspicious transactions and 630 covered dealings worth Php 6.7 billion.
The Commission on Audit has also issued a notice of disallowance to the Office of the Vice President for Php 73.28 million of its confidential funds granted in 2022, according to a decision dated August 8, 2024.
State auditors found that the amount was spent on projects or activities that were not related to the intended purpose of the confidential fund, a decision which the commission later upheld in an April 10 ruling.