Trump vows massive taxes on goods from Mexico, Canada and China

President-elect Donald Trump announced on Monday his intention to implement substantial increases in tariffs on goods originating from Mexico, Canada, and China, effective from the first day of his administration. This policy may significantly raise costs for American businesses and consumers.

Trump articulated that this measure is intended as a response to illegal immigration and the associated issues of crime and drug trafficking crossing the border.

“On January 20th, as one of my many initial Executive Orders, I will sign all necessary documents to impose a 25% Tariff on ALL products imported into the United States from Mexico and Canada, addressing our absurd Open Borders,” Trump stated on his Truth Social platform. “This Tariff will remain in effect until such time as the trafficking of Drugs, particularly Fentanyl, and all Illegal Aliens cease this Invasion of our Country!”

Trump asserted that the United States’ neighboring countries have the capacity to effectively resolve this longstanding issue.

In a similar vein, Trump indicated that China would be subjected to increased tariffs on its products, totaling an additional 10% on top of any pre-existing tariffs, should it fail to curb the influx of illegal drugs into the United States.

“I have engaged in numerous discussions with China regarding the considerable quantities of drugs, especially Fentanyl, being shipped to the United States – yet no progress has been made,” Trump posted on Truth Social.

In his communication, Trump claimed that Chinese officials had assured him that drug dealers responsible for trafficking drugs into the United States would face severe penalties, yet these promises were reportedly not fulfilled.

In response to Trump’s announcement, Chinese Embassy spokesperson Liu Pengyu emphasized that China has been in dialogue with the United States concerning counter-narcotics operations and remarked that “the notion of China deliberately permitting fentanyl precursors to enter the United States contradicts both facts and reality.”

“Regarding the matter of U.S. tariffs on China, China maintains that China-U.S. economic and trade cooperation is inherently mutually beneficial. No party will emerge victorious from a trade war or tariff dispute,” Liu stated in a communication to CNN.

CNN has reached out to the embassies of Mexico and Canada for further comments.

Canadian officials addressed the announcement in a statement posted to X on Monday evening, asserting that their nation “places the highest priority on border security and the integrity of our shared border,” which is “essential to the U.S. domestic energy supply.”

“We will, of course, continue to engage in discussions regarding these matters with the incoming administration,” stated Canada’s Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland and Public Safety Minister Dominic LeBlanc.

A significant policy change

The punishing tariffs, if enacted, could wreak havoc on America’s supply chains and industries reliant on goods from the country’s closest trading partners.

“The measures proposed this evening could hit a number of strategic US industrial sectors hard, add approximately $272 billion a year to tax burdens, raise goods prices, lift interest rates, and sap strength in an already-vulnerable household sector,” said Karl Schamotta, chief market strategist at Corpay Cross-Border Solutions.

After the announcement, the Canadian dollar fell 1.2% against the US dollar, and the Mexican peso fell 2% against the dollar. China’s yuan, though controlled by the government, traded higher – above 7.6% – in offshore markets.

Although investors believed the tariffs could ultimately strengthen the dollar, America’s financial markets took a hit, too. The extraordinary tariffs would raise costs dramatically for Americans for everyday goods that had previously come over the border without any import taxes.

That stunning shift could stymie economic growth, especially if inflation-weary consumers spend less in the face of higher costs.

US stock futures, which were higher before Trump’s announcement, fell somewhat – Dow futures were down 160 points, or 0.3%. Nasdaq futures were 0.4% lower, and the broader S&P 500 was also down 0.4%. US Treasury bond prices fell.

What America imports

The United States’ top import from Canada is oil, which reached a record 4.3 million barrels per day in July, according to the US Energy Information Administration. America also imports cars, machinery and other various commodities, plastics and wood from Canada, according to the United Nations’ Comtrade.

America gets the majority of its cars and car parts from Mexico, which surpassed China as the top exporter to the US in 2023, according to trade data released by the Commerce Department earlier this year. Mexico is also a major supplier of electronics, machinery, oil and optical apparatus, and a significant amount of furniture and alcohol comes from the country into the United States.

The United States imports a significant amount of electronics from China, in addition to machinery, toys, games, sports equipment, furniture and plastics.

During Trump’s first term, CNN reported that he implemented tariffs on about $380 billion worth of goods that applied to thousands of Chinese-made products, including baseball hats, luggage, bicycles, TVs and sneakers. The Trump tariffs also hit foreign steel, aluminum, washing machines and solar panels.

Many US imports from Canada and Mexico are exempted from tariffs because of the USMCA trade agreement between the three nations that Trump pushed for during his first administration. It’s not clear how Trump would plan to implement the proposed tariffs without violating the USMCA.

Trump has routinely referenced the passage of the USMCA, which replaced NAFTA, as a political victory and a highlight of his presidency.

Trump’s tariff plan

Trump campaigned on using tariffs as a cudgel against foreign countries – as he did in his first administration – to grow domestic manufacturing while increasing tax revenue to pay for large revenue gaps that his proposed tax cut plan would create.

Tariffs effectively serve as a tax on goods imported to the United States. Although Trump has repeatedly said targeted foreign countries pay the tariffs, they are in fact paid by companies that purchase the imported goods – and those costs are typically passed onto American consumers. Most mainstream economists believe tariffs will be inflationary, and the Peterson Institute for International Economics has estimated Trump’s proposed tariffs would cost the typical US household over $2,600 a year.

Scott Bessent, Trump’s pick for Treasury secretary, has said that tariffs would not add to inflation if they are implemented correctly. Wall Street cheered Bessent’s appointment, because he is widely expected to roll out tariffs gradually.

Although Bessent, if confirmed by the Senate, will be partly responsible for implementing the tariffs, in coordination with the Commerce secretary and US Trade Representative, Trump as president would wield significant power to levy tariffs with the stroke of a pen. He did just that when he was last in the White House, placing large tariffs on goods, primarily from China.

The problem with tariffs is that they often result in retaliatory actions by targeted countries, kicking off a trade war – and that’s exactly what happened during Trump’s first term. That blunted the tariffs’ effect on domestic manufacturing, because manufacturers’ goods became less attractive to overseas buyers.

Trump has promised significantly larger tariffs during his second term. Although he continues to discuss many different numbers, he has proposed a tariff upward of 60% on all Chinese goods, as well as an across-the-board tariff of either 10% or 20% on all other imports into the US.

This story has been updated with additional context and developments.

Leave a Reply