US Judge orders White House to restore AP’s access to presidential events

A US federal judge has ruled that the White House must restore the Associated Press’s (AP) access to President Donald Trump’s official events, finding that denying the news agency access based on its “viewpoint” violated the First Amendment of the US Constitution. The order comes after the White House barred AP journalists and photographers from the Oval Office and Air Force One starting in mid-February, following the agency’s refusal to change its reference to the “Gulf of Mexico” to “Gulf of America,” as decreed by Trump.

District Judge Trevor McFadden ruled that the White House’s exclusion of the AP, which was based solely on the news agency’s editorial decision regarding place names, was a form of “viewpoint-based denial of access,” which infringes upon the constitutional guarantee of freedom of speech and of the press.

“If the Government opens its doors to some journalists, it cannot then shut those doors to other journalists because of their viewpoints,” McFadden stated. “The Government has singled out the AP because of its refusal to update the Gulf’s name in its Stylebook.”

The judge ordered that the White House immediately rescind its denial of access to AP reporters and photographers in the Oval Office, Air Force One, and other press spaces, where they are granted access alongside other members of the White House press pool.

While the White House has five days to respond or appeal the decision, AP spokeswoman Lauren Easton welcomed the ruling. “Today’s ruling affirms the fundamental right of the press and public to speak freely without government retaliation,” Easton said. “This is a freedom guaranteed for all Americans in the US Constitution.”

The AP filed the lawsuit after it was denied access to certain presidential events. AP lawyer Charles Tobin argued that the exclusion was a form of “abject retaliation” for the agency’s editorial stance on the Gulf of Mexico’s name. The White House’s change in policy, which included a new system for determining press pool members, was seen as further exclusionary, with the AP notably left out of the rotation.

Judge McFadden acknowledged that while the AP did not have an absolute constitutional right to enter the Oval Office, it had the right not to be excluded due to its viewpoint. He also pointed out the financial and business impact the restrictions had on the AP, noting that its economic condition was worsening as its customers turned to other news services in response to the exclusion.

In its defense, the AP emphasized that the Gulf of Mexico has been known by that name for over 400 years and that it would continue to refer to it by its original name while acknowledging the alternative name chosen by Trump. The 180-year-old news agency has long been a cornerstone of US journalism and continues to supply news to outlets around the world.

The White House Correspondents’ Association (WHCA) also expressed approval of the ruling, celebrating the decision to allow AP journalists back into presidential events. “We are thrilled Associated Press reporters, photographers, and video journalists are to be allowed back into presidential events from which they had been banned by the administration just for using words the White House did not like,” the WHCA stated.

Leave a Reply