
Republicans avoided a confirmation firestorm when former Rep. Matt Gaetz withdrew from consideration as attorney general, but lawmakers on Capitol Hill are already bracing for how they’ll navigate the next slew of unorthodox Donald Trump picks. They have warned the president-elect’s choice to lead the Pentagon, who faces controversy over his past comments and history, that the confirmation process is a long and invasive journey.
Some of Trump’s Cabinet selections, including Pete Hegseth, Trump’s pick for Secretary of Defense, and Tulsi Gabbard, his pick for director of national intelligence, could force Republicans to choose between their allegiance to Trump and their growing concerns that some of his nominees might not be up for the job or might face significant challenges in a narrowly controlled Senate.
On Thursday, Hegseth huddled with a handful of Republican senators, many seen as close allies of Trump, for a series of meetings aimed at rallying support ahead of the confirmation process. Lawmakers who emerged from these discussions included Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee, who described it as “a great meeting,” and Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma, who labeled Hegseth as “very qualified to do the job.”
However, on the same day that these senators were voicing their support, new distressing details emerged regarding a police report from 2017. In this report, a woman alleged that Hegseth had blocked her from leaving a hotel room, taken her phone, and then sexually assaulted her, stating that she “remembered saying ‘no’ a lot,” as reported by CNN. Although police declined to press charges, Hegseth has consistently maintained that the encounter was consensual.
Despite some members of the Republican Party signaling support for Hegseth’s nomination, a growing number of Republicans on Capitol Hill are voicing serious concerns regarding his candidacy. Many senators have known him for years as a Fox News host, but the process of vetting him for Secretary of Defense will compel them to reassess his views and past behavior under a new and critical lens.
Republicans have been clear with Hegseth about the challenges he will face — as they had been with Gaetz before he withdrew from consideration — emphasizing that the confirmation process will be lengthy and require repeated meetings with sometimes-skeptical senators. This will culminate in a high-stakes confirmation hearing that will likely delve deeply into the allegations against him. Additionally, aides and senators warn that this scrutiny will occur before they critically evaluate how equipped he is to lead a massive entity like the Pentagon, particularly given his limited experience in such high-level positions.
Another pressing issue is Hegseth’s previous statements on women in combat roles in the military. With only a slim 53-seat majority in the Senate, the dynamics of supporting Hegseth and other Trump nominees present a precarious situation for Republicans, who can afford to lose only three votes, leaving little room for error.
In a sign of the potential challenges ahead for Trump’s picks, GOP Senator Kevin Cramer expressed on Thursday that the sexual assault allegation against Hegseth is “pretty concerning,” although he clarified that he would not prejudge Hegseth before the Senate had an opportunity to thoroughly vet him.
Hegseth isn’t the only Trump nominee facing scrutiny. Former Rep. Tulsi Gabbard, selected for director of national intelligence, is being watched closely by Republicans. Gabbard has come under increased criticism for her views on surveillance and the agencies that conduct it, jeopardizing her confirmation process. “If we are ranking the most in trouble, she’s No. 1,” warned one GOP aide, indicating the heightened concern around her nomination.
Senator James Lankford, who is the newest addition to the Senate Republican leadership team, addressed these concerns during an interview on CNN’s “State of the Union.” He stated that they will have “lots of questions” concerning Trump’s selection for the director of national intelligence. He specifically noted, “There’s comments that are floating out there, but we want to be able to know the rest of the story,” emphasizing the need for a thorough understanding of Gabbard’s positions and past remarks.
Additionally, another Trump selection surrounded by controversy is Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the president-elect’s pick to lead the Department of Health and Human Services. Kennedy’s skepticism regarding vaccines continues to raise alarms among a segment of lawmakers, contributing to the complexities that these nominations present for the Republican party as they navigate an unprecedented confirmation landscape.
Republicans navigate vetting process after Gaetz withdraws
Gaetz’s swift withdrawal underscored that even with Republicans soon to control both chambers of Congress as well as the White House, the president-elect will still face at least some hurdles ahead.
Gaetz pulled himself from consideration after he made his own trek to Capitol Hill on Wednesday for meetings with GOP senators, seeking to shore up support for his nomination. But on Thursday morning, Trump called Gaetz with bad news: He did not have the votes in the Senate to win confirmation, according to a source with direct knowledge of the call.
As news of Gaetz’s decision to opt out of seeking the attorney general post spread to senators on Capitol Hill, many members — who knew that Gaetz would be difficult to confirm — were struck by a sense of relief.
“It was going to be very challenging. Very challenging. The most challenging of the nominees,” said one Republican senator, speaking on the condition of background to speak freely.
Some of the selections so far have also raised questions over the level of vetting Trump’s picks are getting before the president-elect announces a name. Trump’s transition team was in the middle of announcing new Cabinet picks when they were informed of the sexual assault allegation against Hegseth, CNN reported, stunning several members of the team.
Asked about how the Trump team is vetting potential nominees, Cramer told reporters, “That’s their concern — if they don’t want to vet more, or if they want to take a chance on these, that’s up to them. Our job will be to vet. If they don’t, we will; if they do, we will.”
Pressed on whether the allegation Hegseth faces gives him pause, Cramer said, “It’s a pretty big problem, given that we have a sexual assault problem in our military.”
“This is why you have background checks, it’s why you have hearings, this is why you go through the scrutiny. I’m not going to prejudge him, but, yeah, it’s a pretty concerning accusation,” he said.
Hegseth claimed on Thursday that due to the lack of charges, he was “completely cleared” in an investigation into the allegation made against him.
“As far as the media is concerned, I’ll keep this very simple. The matter was fully investigated, and I was completely cleared. That’s where I’m going to leave it,” he told reporters.
While no charges were filed, the report does not say that police found the allegations to be false, which Hegseth’s attorney has claimed.
His attorney has acknowledged that Hegseth later entered into a settlement agreement with his accuser that included an undisclosed monetary payment and a confidentiality clause. Though Hegseth insisted the encounter was consensual, the lawyer said he was fearful that the woman was poised to make an allegation against him during the #MeToo movement that might cost him his job as a Fox News host.
Mullin said that Hegseth voluntarily brought up the sexual assault allegation against him in a meeting on Capitol Hill. Based on the police report, Mullin said he does not view the incident as a sexual assault.
“He voluntarily talked about it,” Mullin told reporters after the meeting. “Obviously, we head-started it. It’s a topic that’s gonna be discussed.”
On Sunday, the Oklahoma Republican continued his vigorous defense of Hegseth, stressing on CNN that he had not been charged with a crime.
“It’s what’s unfortunate in today’s world, you can be accused of anything, and then if, especially if it’s something like this, you’re automatically assumed to be guilty,” he said on “State of the Union.”
Pressed on Hegseth’s comments that women should not be able to serve in combat, Mullin emphasized that the president-elect would make the final decision.
“I have three girls. I don’t want them to be limited,” he told Bash. “But who ultimately makes that decision is President Trump. And President Trump respects every person serving in the military, regardless of male or female. There’s no limitations.”