SCS tensions boil over as US slams China’s ‘fabricated’ Scarborough Shoal victory claim

The waters off Scarborough Shoal are once again at the center of a geopolitical firestorm — and this time, both Washington and Beijing are doubling down on their own versions of the truth.

China’s state-run media proudly claimed this week that its military “warned and expelled” the USS Higgins, a U.S. guided missile destroyer, from the vicinity of the disputed atoll. But the U.S. Navy fired back, flatly branding the statement a fabrication — and accusing Beijing of spinning propaganda to mask its own aggressive behavior in the South China Sea.

“This mission went exactly as planned. No warnings, no expulsions, no drama,” insisted Commander Megan Greene, spokesperson for the U.S. 7th Fleet. “China’s statement is false. The Higgins was operating under international law and continued its mission without incident.”

The incident — or non-incident, depending on whose story you believe — came just two days after a collision between Chinese vessels near the shoal, adding fuel to an already volatile atmosphere. Greene emphasized that the destroyer’s freedom of navigation operation challenged “unlawful restrictions” Beijing has tried to impose in the area, before sailing on to other missions in the South China Sea.

Meanwhile, the USS Cincinnati, a littoral combat ship, was also spotted operating roughly 30 nautical miles from Scarborough, further enraging Chinese officials.

The flashpoint is no small matter. China’s sweeping claim over Panatag Shoal, rejected by the 2016 Hague Arbitral Award, has long been seen by analysts as a thinly veiled power grab. But Beijing has treated the ruling like a bad joke — erecting what maritime experts describe as a de facto “exclusion zone” that ignores international law and sidelines Filipino fishermen who have relied on the shoal for generations.

Critics say both superpowers are using the West Philippine Sea as a theater for strategic posturing — with the Philippines caught in the middle. China’s “victory narrative” plays well at home, bolstering nationalist pride. The U.S.’s “freedom of navigation” mantra reassures allies but also risks turning contested waters into a live-fire accident waiting to happen.

For now, the only thing clear is that the battle for truth is as fierce as the battle for control. As one Filipino maritime advocate warned, “If they keep testing each other here, one day, someone’s going to stop pretending — and start shooting.”

Leave a Reply