House urges Senate to hold off on VP Duterte impeachment trial until SC resolves appeal

Close-up of a woman appearing frustrated and gesturing emphatically, with a dimly lit background.

In a brewing constitutional standoff, the House of Representatives is urging the Senate to hold its fire on any decision regarding the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte until the Supreme Court fully resolves the matter. This appeal comes in response to a recent high court ruling that declared the House’s impeachment articles against Duterte unconstitutional—a decision the lower chamber intends to contest.

House spokesperson Atty. Princess Abante emphasized that the Supreme Court’s decision is not yet final, and therefore any Senate action based on it would be premature. “We call on our dear Senators to exercise prudence and patience,” Abante said. “The House remains committed to the rule of law and will exhaust all legal remedies to protect its constitutional mandate.”

The heart of the issue lies in the Supreme Court’s 13-0-2 ruling which stated that the impeachment complaint against Duterte violated the constitutional one-year bar and infringed on her right to due process. As a result, the court concluded that the Senate could not acquire jurisdiction over the case. However, the Court left the door open for a new complaint to be filed starting February 6, 2026.

Despite the clarity of the ruling, Senate President Francis “Chiz” Escudero said the Senate is set to deliberate on the SC decision on August 6. Senate President Pro Tempore Jinggoy Estrada has already noted that a majority of senators—19 to 20—appear poised to uphold the Supreme Court’s findings.

The House, however, sees the looming Senate vote as premature and potentially damaging to the constitutional process. “Any action that appears to abandon the impeachment trial without hearing our motion for reconsideration may be interpreted as an erosion of due process,” said Abante. “Worse, it could be seen as a political shortcut that undermines the role of the House.”

The tension between legislative chambers adds another layer of complexity to an already politically charged situation. While some senators remain deferential to the Supreme Court, others are reportedly reviewing legal opinions—including one draft resolution circulating that relies on the counsel of former justices.

Senator Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa made his stance clear in a Saturday post, stating that he refuses to sign any resolution questioning the Supreme Court’s decision. “I’m not a lawyer,” he wrote, “but I know how to respect and follow the ruling of the Supreme Court.”

Adding to the growing call for restraint, the Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) issued a statement supporting the Supreme Court’s ruling and criticizing any attempts to challenge it outside legal means. “Defying the decision erodes the foundations of our legal system,” the IBP warned. “The Constitution does not require agreement. It demands adherence.”

At its core, this impasse pits two of the country’s co-equal branches of government against each other in a legal tug-of-war. For now, the House is asking the Senate to respect the appeals process and uphold the principle that accountability must be pursued within the bounds of the Constitution, not outside of it.

Leave a Reply