Ethel Cain expands Preacher’s Daughter lore with her latest song, ‘Nettles’

“To love me is to suffer me,” a wise yearner once said. 

There is no need to ask if it’s too late to join Ethel Cain’s journey, as the artist marks the expansion of her ongoing concept project, with “Nettles”—serving as the lead single from her upcoming sophomore album, “Willoughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You.”  

Photo Courtesy of Rolling Stone

The alternative singer-songwriter Hayden Anhedönia, also known by her stage name Ethel Cain, which is also the name of the protagonist in the story, began the project on her debut album, “Preacher’s Daughter” (2022).

For starters, Preacher’s Daughter is an experimental album that incorporates elements of dark ambient, folk, and other experimental genres, with thematic visual concepts that explore religion, Southern Gothic imagery, and American culture. 

Set in 1991 in Shady Grove, Alabama, it narrates Ethel Cain’s tumultuous life revolving around family dynamics, generational trauma, love, violence, and death (spoilers ahead), all of which she experiences as the album progresses, each track. 

“These crosses all over my body, remind me of how I used to be” is an unapologetic introductory verse in “Family Tree,” setting the tone for the entirety of the album and letting listeners know what they signed up for, which the main character’s religious environment and upbringing get to delve further.

“American Teenager” is a sonically radio-friendly track that echoes Ethel’s sentiments as she searches for her identity and purpose in life while striving to live up to the legacy of her late father, a beloved preacher in her hometown. The guitar strings in its instrumentals interpolate Journey’s classic, “Don’t Stop Believin’,” delivering an uplifting and nostalgic feel throughout the song. 

The song was also featured on former US President Barack Obama’s 2022 Favorite Music year-end list, which is said to have given Ethel Cain traction and recognition later on. 

In the latter part of the album, the tracks “Thoroughfare,” “Gibson Girl,” and “Strangers” subsequently recount the protagonist’s encounter with Isaiah Abram—Ethel Cain’s love interest, who would later become the perpetrator of her tragic fate, leading to her death in an unexpected turn of events.

“A House in Nebraska” is the lone song on the album that reminisces about Ethel Cain’s past in a positive light, specifically her first love interest in high school, which would later be known as Willboughy Tucker, as referenced with the announcement of her upcoming album and its title.

In retrospect, Willoughby, Tucker I’ll Always Love You (2025) will be a prequel in the Ethel Cain lore, set in 1986, five years before the events of “Preacher’s Daughter” (2022), rather than a sequel, albeit its continuation.

Give it a try, along with Nettles; who knows? It might be next on your go-to and on-repeat playlist.  

In recent years, concept albums have gained adoration. It became a new avenue for artists to showcase their songwriting and storytelling creativity. For listeners, these works offer more enjoyable experiences as they decode “easter eggs,” provide their self-interpretations in songs and share their insights with other music fans. 

In terms of production and cohesion, critics consider Ethel Cain’s ongoing anthology to be on par with other remarkable concept albums, such as the Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967), David Bowie’s Ziggy Stardust (1972), Pink Floyd’s The Dark Side of the Moon (1973), Beyoncé’s Lemonade (2016), and Taylor Swift’s Folklore (2020). 

Ahead of the album’s August 8 release, Ethel Cain announced worldwide pre-orders in CD, vinyl, and cassette formats starting on Friday, June 6, making favorable momentum and hype for her, as she also recently made history as the first-ever openly transgender female artist to have an album peak in the top 10 of Billboard Chart—a milestone timely with pride month.

Leave a Reply