Court of Appeals orders ERC Chair Dimalanta to inhibit from NGCP rate reset case

The Court of Appeals (CA) has ordered Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) Chairperson Monalisa Dimalanta to recuse herself from the ongoing rate reset application proceedings of the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines (NGCP), citing grave abuse of discretion.

In a 22-page decision promulgated on April 30, the CA Special 11th Division granted NGCP’s petition for certiorari filed in July 2024, which claimed that Dimalanta prejudged the 4th regulatory period reset process through public statements made as early as October 2022—even before NGCP filed its application.

The CA highlighted that ERC denied NGCP’s urgent motion to suspend the proceedings in February 2023. However, despite NGCP filing nine motions to reconsider and to resolve the matter, the ERC failed to act. The appellate court noted that NGCP’s motion for reconsideration had been pending since April 20, 2023.

“[Dimalanta] committed grave abuse of discretion in refusing to inhibit from the 4th regulatory RP proceedings,” the ruling stated. “She neglected to resolve petitioner’s motion for reconsideration for an unreasonable period of more than one year.”

The CA also pointed out that Dimalanta’s public remarks, suggesting a reduction in transmission charges, constituted prejudgment.

“It is apparent that respondent had already prejudged the result of the reset application proceedings well before petitioner filed the same and presented any evidence,” the ruling read. “Respondent could not be expected to render a fair judgment when she already has an outcome in mind, waiting only to be formalized after petitioner undergoes the charade of a formal hearing.”

In response, Dimalanta told ABS-CBN News she has not yet received a copy of the decision and has not reviewed it.

The fourth regulatory period in question covers 2016 to 2022. Dimalanta previously stated that deliberations began in January 2024 but were taking time due to the large volume of public comments.

ERC Commissioner Catherine Maceda earlier said delays stemmed from 2016, when Meralco failed to publish draft rules for the rate reset due to issues it raised with the ERC.

In February, lawmakers approved a motion to audit ERC’s actions during the lapse period to determine the reasons behind the delays in the reset process.

Leave a Reply