
The Commission on Human Rights (CHR) urged Congress to ensure that hospital management, not staff, bears responsibility under the Anti-Hospital Detention Law (RA 9439).
In a statement on Friday, CHR said the measure should reflect “proportional and differentiated accountability,” noting that personnel who implement policies should not be penalized for decisions made by administrators.
“This reflects the human rights principle that those in authority bear responsibility for institutional practices that lead to violations,” the commission added.
CHR highlighted that hospital detention violates the Bill of Rights under the 1987 Philippine Constitution by depriving patients of their liberty and dignity.
The proposed amendments seek to strengthen protections by widening coverage, imposing stricter penalties, and ensuring effective implementation, including revising Section 3 of the law.
Under the proposal, hospital staff who improperly detain patients or cadavers may face six months to two years imprisonment and fines, while directors or officers enforcing policy-driven violations could face four to six years imprisonment and higher fines. Repeated breaches may prompt the Department of Health (DOH) to revoke a hospital’s license.
CHR also recommended a tiered system of penalties, such as suspension or compliance audits, and clearer rules for victims to claim civil and administrative remedies. The position paper was signed by CHR Chairperson Richard Palpal-Latoc and four commissioners in November 2025.