
MANILA – The Court of Appeals has affirmed the Baguio Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 59’s ruling to fine a woman PHP50,000 after finding her guilty of cyber libel.
In its 15-page decision released on Wednesday, the appellate court denied Ashlyn Akian’s appeal, with the modification of subsidiary imprisonment in case of non-payment of the penalty. The complainant discovered the messages when she borrowed the common friend’s phone.
In one message, the accused referred to the complainant as old, ugly, filthy and part of a group of mistresses. The message was sent to a common friend and was sent shortly after the accused was banned from the complainant’s house for being overbearing.
The accused, for her part, said the conversation was private and referred to another person, and not the complainant.
Ruling otherwise, the court said, “the claim of accused-appellant fails under the reasonable expectation of privacy test.”
“Here, although accused-appellant may reasonably have expected that her Facebook Messenger account itself would remain inaccessible to unauthorized persons, the same conclusion does not necessarily extend to messages that she voluntarily sent to Ashley (their common friend),” the court added.
By sending the messages to Ashley, the CA said the accused-appellant necessarily placed the contents of the message within Ashley’s possession and knowledge.
“She could no longer reasonably expect, as against Ashley, that the latter would have no access to, retain no copy of, or otherwise possess the communications deliberately sent to her,” it said.
“This does not mean that every private message loses all protection from the moment it is transmitted. Rather, the sender’s reasonable expectation of privacy is necessarily limited with respect to the intended recipient, who has been voluntarily given access to the communication,” the tribunal added. (Benjamin Pulta/PNA)