
Photo courtesy of Philippine News Agency.
House prosecutor and Akbayan Rep. Chel Diokno said parties in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial may still speak publicly about the proceedings without automatically violating the sub judice rule.
Diokno said Thursday that the restriction does not impose a blanket ban on discussing a pending case. He said the key consideration was whether a statement was intended to influence the outcome of the proceedings.
His remarks followed an accusation by Duterte’s lead defense counsel Shiela Sison that private prosecutor Amando Virgil Ligutan violated the rule through a social media post after Wednesday’s hearing.
Ligutan had commented on an exchange between defense lawyer Kristine Ferrer and private prosecutor Lorna Kapunan over whether misleading questions may be asked during cross-examination.
Diokno drew a distinction between the sub judice rule and restrictions imposed under the Senate’s impeachment rules. He said prosecutors and defense lawyers were barred from publicly discussing the merits of the impeachment case, including testimony, documents and other evidence presented before the court.
Public discussion of legal principles and procedures, however, was not necessarily prohibited. “When it comes to sub judice, it is not prohibited to speak about a pending case,” Diokno said.
He also said factual news coverage of what transpired during a hearing would not amount to a sub judice violation. Lawyers, whether involved in the proceedings or not, could similarly explain legal concepts without necessarily crossing the line.
Diokno maintained that both the prosecution and defense should have an opportunity to discuss the proceedings within legal limits. House prosecutors have also called for restrictions on public statements to be enforced equally among those involved, including Duterte and the senator-judges.