CA cites ERC Chair for abuse of discretion and bias; orders her to inhibit

Signage of the Court of Appeals building showcasing the name prominently.

The Court of Appeals has delivered a stinging rebuke to Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) Chairperson Monalisa Dimalanta, ruling that she committed a grave abuse of authority and displayed clear bias in handling the rate reset application of the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines (NGCP).

In a decision dated April 30, 2025, the appellate court ordered Dimalanta to inhibit herself from further involvement in the regulatory proceedings, particularly NGCP’s 4th Regulatory Period (RP) reset application. The court found that her continued participation in the case was incompatible with the principles of fairness and impartiality required of public officials overseeing quasi-judicial processes.

“We find that respondent gravely abused her discretion when she refused to inhibit from the proceedings a quo despite her evident bias and partiality against the petitioner,” the ruling stated.

The court’s order came in response to a petition for certiorari filed by NGCP, which accused Dimalanta of prejudging its case. NGCP argued that the ERC chair made several public statements in 2022 indicating that transmission rates would be reduced—remarks made before NGCP had even filed its formal application in December that year.

The appellate court highlighted that Dimalanta made these statements despite knowing NGCP had not yet submitted its application, suggesting a “preconceived outcome” and a lack of neutrality. The court concluded that such conduct deprived NGCP of its right to a fair and impartial regulatory hearing.

“Respondent could not be expected to render a fair judgment when she already has an outcome in mind… By issuing premature public statements, respondent somehow deprived petitioner of its right to a fair and impartial administrative process,” the decision read.

NGCP also raised concerns over the ERC’s inaction on nine motions it filed in 2023, further reinforcing claims of bias and regulatory neglect.

The controversy traces back to ERC rules issued in September 2022 requiring NGCP to submit data for its 4th RP Reset, covering 2016 to 2022. Just a month later, Dimalanta held a press briefing forecasting a drop in rates—well before any application review could begin.

With the court now ordering her removal from the case, Dimalanta’s impartiality and leadership at the ERC are under serious scrutiny. The ruling underscores the judiciary’s role in checking regulatory overreach and protecting the integrity of administrative proceedings.

Leave a Reply