A Chinese Conspiracy

Portrait of Tracy Cabrera with a circular frame, featuring gray hair and glasses, set against a textured white background with faint text.

The government is so out of control. It is so bloated and infested with fraud and deceit and corruption and abuse of power.

— American singer and guitarist Ted Nugent

Amidst the flood control fiasco that has shaken the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) from the agency’s foundation to its rafters, it appears that it is the favorite playground for irregularities as China is now trying to manipulate the bidding for the country’s longest bridge—the 32.15-kilometer Bataan-Cavite Interlink Bridge that will connect the two provinces across the span of historic Manila Bay.

According to our sources, five state-owned construction companies from China are tendering for the ₱210-billion Bridge project that will links Mariveles in Bataan to Naic in Cavite.

On paper, it looks like healthy competition but in reality, the five bids are not independent and are actually coordinated to be 20 to 30 percent below market rate with Beijing subsidizing the losses. One realizes that in effect, the five Chinese bidders they are actually one and the same bidder—the Chinese government.

The fact is that multiple bids from the same government do not promote fair competition. They only create an illusion of choice. It’s like the Discayas fielding five of their nine construction outfits to bid for the same flood control project. After bagging it they take the money and run.

New public works secretary Vivencio ‘Vince’ Dizon should look into this mess that he inherited and the Philippine Competition Commission (PCC) must scrutinize the opening of bids late this month.

There are eight bidders for the Manila Bay Bridge project. Five are Chinese, namely the China Harbor Engineering Company, Beijing Urban Construction Group Limited, China Wu Yi Ltd., Shou Road & Bridge Group and Human Road & Bridge-China Civil Engineering Joint Venture.

They are conspiring to elbow out the three Filipino companies POSCO E&C-Sta. Clara Int’l Corporation JV, EEI Corporation-PMI JV and D.M. Consunji Incorporated.

It’s also worth to note that all major Chinese builders fall under Beijing’s State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission (SASAC). They share the same lenders: Export-Import Bank of China and China Development Bank. Also the same insurer: Sinosure.

Knowing this, it’s a sure way of inviting disaster. SASAC contractors bid low but projects are often substandard in materials and workmanship.

Examples have been cited:

• In Ecuador, the Coca-Codo Sinclair Dam was built by multiple Chinese state-owned enterprises. Thousands of cracks appeared within three years. None of the Chinese contractors took responsibility.

• In Montenegro, China Road & Bridge Corporation built the Bar-Boljare motorway. With a US$944-million bid, it was only able to finish 41 kilometers, 130-km short of required. To finish the project, it demanded another US$1 billion.

• In Kenya, the Kenyatta International Convention Center renovation was estimated at 1.94 billion Shilling, but ballooned to 3.2 billion Shilling due to under-specifications.

• In Nigeria, the Changjiang Construction Nigerian Ltd. renovated Kogi Specialist Hospital, later found to be substandard.

• In Vietnam, Chinese contractors built Da Nang-Quang Ngai Expressway Phase 2. Courts later ordered the builders to recompense Vietnam US$18.7 million for low quality output.

• In Indonesia, several Chinese state firms bid low to bag the Jakarta-Bandung highspeed railway. They couldn’t finish it, so the Indonesian government had to put in US$2 billion more.

Another thing, Chinese state firms are notorious for bribery. In 2009, the World Bank blacklisted China State Construction Engineering Corporation and China Geo Engineering Corp. for bid collusion in Philippine roadworks. Both are subsidiaries of China Road & Bridge Corp. that bungled in Montenegro.

In 2012, Dalian Rail Corp. bribed several executives of the Department of Transportation (DoTr) ₱190 million to supply 48 MRT-3 coaches worth ₱3.8 billion. All 48 were faulty, undersized, overweight, unusable.

* * *

FOR your comments or suggestions, complaints or requests, just send a message through my email at cipcab2006@yahoo.com or text me at cellphone numbers 09171656792 or 09171592256 during office hours from Monday to Friday. Thank you and mabuhay!

Leave a Reply