VP Sara Duterte’s lawyers oppose house motion to reverse SC ruling

Vice President Sara Duterte’s legal team on Tuesday filed their comment opposing the House of Representatives’ motion to reverse the Supreme Court (SC) decision that dismissed her impeachment case.

In a 27-page filing, lead lawyer Philip Sigfrid Fortun said the SC’s July 25 ruling “requires no factual correction” as “it rests on an unshaken foundation of truth.”

The House, through the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), seeks to overturn the unanimous SC decision declaring the Articles of Impeachment unconstitutional. The court had ruled that the complaint violated the one-year rule under Article XI, Section 3, paragraph 5 of the Constitution and infringed on Duterte’s right to due process.

Lawmakers argued the SC’s due process requirements “unduly interfere” with Congress’ authority to conduct impeachment proceedings.

Duterte’s lawyers countered that the ruling was based on “substantive legal ground” and not “immaterial details.” They also questioned the validity of the House’s motion, stating that Congress is not a continuing body and the OSG filed the appeal without plenary approval.

“Absent this approval by the plenary, the motion is unauthorized and legally infirm. It is a nullity that usurps the institutional authority of the 20th Congress itself,” the defense said.

Leave a Reply