The Supreme Court has officially abandoned the “second placer rule,” which previously guided the Commission on Elections (Comelec) in cases involving disqualified or ineligible winning candidates. In a decision issued on April 22, 2025, the court stated that the rule established in the 2012 case of Jalosjos Jr. vs. Comelec lacked legal basis, as there is no law permitting the proclamation of the second placer.
The court ruled that the succession rules under Republic Act No. 7160, or the Local Government Code, should apply instead. “In fine, the Court hereby abandons the second placer rule and declares that the rules on succession under the LGC shall apply in all cases where a permanent vacancy results from a local elective official’s disqualification from office regardless of the proceedings involved,” the decision, penned by Associate Justice Samuel Gaerlan, stated.
This ruling arose from a petition filed by Datu Pax Ali Mangudadatu against the Comelec and his opponent in the 2022 gubernatorial elections in Sultan Kudarat, Sarifa Akeel Mangudadatu. Although Pax Ali won the election, the Comelec canceled his certificate of candidacy (COC), citing material misrepresentation regarding his residency.
The court noted that Pax Ali’s resignation as mayor of Datu Abdullah Sangki was viewed as an afterthought, emphasizing that he had filed his COC while still in office. The court revisited the second placer rule, highlighting its rejection as early as 1929 in the case of Nuval vs. Guray due to lack of legal support.
In its 2025 ruling, the court reaffirmed that the Local Government Code’s succession rules should prevail, declaring that Raden Sakaluran, the duly elected vice governor of Sultan Kudarat in the 2022 elections, will serve the remainder of the term from July 1, 2022, to June 30, 2025.
However, Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen and several other justices dissented, with Leonen arguing that while Pax Ali did not meet the residency requirement, the second placer should be considered the first placer among qualified candidates.