Senator-judges scrutinize Cale88 workforce, cash inflows

(Screengrab from Senate livestream)

MANILA, Philippines – Senator-judges on Friday, November 20, questioned discrepancies in Cale88’s reported workforce and financial records after comparing the company’s approximately P208 million in declared sales with P776 million in corporate inflows reflected in Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) records.

During the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, Senate President Win Gatchalian pressed Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo to explain the difference between the company’s reported sales and the substantially higher amount of money that entered its accounts.

Rodolfo confirmed that Cale88’s audited sales from 2022 to 2025 totaled approximately P208 million.

Gatchalian then presented AMLC records showing around P776 million in corporate inflows and questioned why the amount was significantly higher than the company’s declared sales.

The Senate President also cited P20 million in shareholder advances reflected in Cale88’s balance sheet, noting that even if the amount were added to the reported sales, the total would remain far below the AMLC figure.

“Kahit na idagdag yung advances, dahil inflow rin yan, hindi aabot ng 776,” Gatchalian said.

Rodolfo maintained that the Board of Investments (BOI) relied on financial statements and other documents submitted by Cale88, which did not provide a basis for reporting revenues higher than the declared figures.

The discussion also covered bank certifications submitted for value-added tax (VAT) zero-rating applications.

Rodolfo said the available certifications for 2023 and 2025 amounted to USD721,283, equivalent to approximately P41.83 million using an illustrative exchange rate of P58 per dollar.

However, he acknowledged that the BOI had no corresponding bank certification for 2024, when Cale88 reported its highest export sales of approximately P150 million.

“So wala po kaming kopya ng bank certificate,” Rodolfo said, explaining that the company had not submitted a corresponding VAT zero-rating application for that period.

Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo also questioned whether a company with relatively limited capital and manpower could generate more than P700 million in sales over three to four years.

Rodolfo explained that the BOI had evaluated Cale88’s proposed investments and production capacity based on its business plan, which included a project cost of approximately P12 million.

When pressed on whether the company could realistically generate the amount cited by Tulfo, Rodolfo declined to make an assessment.

“I have no capacity to make that judgment,” he said.

Discrepancies in workforce records questioned

Senator-Judge Joel Villanueva raised concerns over inconsistencies in Cale88’s employee disclosures, particularly a General Information Sheet (GIS) indicating zero rank-and-file employees despite separate reports showing significantly higher workforce figures.

Villanueva cited company submissions indicating 115 workers in one period and 50 in another, questioning how these figures aligned with the company’s reported operations.

“Anong dahilan? Bakit magkaiba po?” Villanueva asked.

Rodolfo admitted that BOI personnel did not physically verify whether the 50 workers identified in the company’s inspection report were actually present.

“Hindi po nagbilang yung mga tao namin kung meron talagang 50 na physically na nandun po ng mga tao. Ang basehan po yung kanilang notarized na submission,” he explained.

The DTI official said the BOI relied on the company’s notarized Form S1 and compared reported labor figures with information in its annual financial statements.

During his earlier testimony, Rodolfo identified 115 direct-labor workers and four administrative or sales employees in Cale88’s 2023 submission.

For 2025, he reported that the company’s GIS listed only two rank-and-file employees and two officers.

Rodolfo also acknowledged that direct-labor figures did not necessarily represent regular employees, as some workers could have been engaged under different employment arrangements.

Villanueva questioned whether the company’s reported manpower was sufficient to support its accounting, treasury, human resources, and production requirements.

P193.95 million remittance from China examined

Villanueva also questioned a P193.95 million remittance from China National Township Enterprise to Cale88.

The senator identified the Chinese company as a reported subsidiary of China National Agricultural Development Group, which he described as a state-owned enterprise.

He asked whether the BOI required additional disclosures when Philippine companies conducted transactions with foreign state-owned corporations.

Rodolfo explained that the agency’s standard documentary requirements did not automatically establish whether a foreign company was government-owned.

He said the BOI primarily relied on export sales declared in Cale88’s notarized Form S1 reports.

“Ang pinagbabasehan lang po namin ang export sales niya ay yun pong dineclare niya dun sa S1,” Rodolfo said.

However, he clarified that certain VAT-related applications included bank remittance certificates identifying the sender and receiving account.

Rodolfo said he would need to examine the relevant records to determine whether China National Township Enterprise appeared in the company’s submissions.

Villanueva emphasized that the transactions were included in the prosecution’s forensic financial report, which examined substantial foreign remittances received by Cale88.

Lacson seeks shipping records to verify transactions

Meanwhile, Senator-Judge Panfilo Lacson pressed the defense to present shipping documents, waybills, and other supporting records to establish whether Cale88’s foreign remittances corresponded to legitimate business transactions.

Lacson stressed that the central issue was not merely whether the company had registered with the BOI, but whether its financial transactions were supported by actual commercial activities.

He said the documents could help determine whether concerns that Cale88 might have been used for money laundering had any factual basis.

“Ang gusto naming makita ‘yung proof, at least ‘yung records, ‘yung waybill, ‘yung shipping records,” Lacson said.

The senator emphasized that possible money laundering remained a matter for examination and had not been established as a finding.

He added that presenting the relevant shipping and transaction records could help the defense challenge the prosecution’s forensic financial analysis and clarify the nature of the company’s foreign remittances.

Defense counsel Michael Poa assured the impeachment court that additional defense witnesses would be presented to address the questions raised by the senator-judges.

“We’re waiting for that,” Lacson responded.

The questioning highlighted continuing concerns over the differences between Cale88’s declared business operations, employee records, and substantial financial inflows as the Senate impeachment court examined evidence under the remaining article of impeachment against Vice President Duterte.

Leave a Reply