
By Jose Cielito Reganit
MANILA – Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo criticized the quality of Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense witnesses on Thursday, as fellow senator-judges questioned how lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente would challenge a forensic report the defense had not supplied him.
“Mahina po yung the witnesses that you’re presenting here these past few days (are weak),” he said.
Tulfo said he was expressing his opinion while urging the defense to present witnesses prepared to answer substantive questions.
Tulfo questioned the value of testimony without reviewing the financial documents, including covered and suspicious transaction reports.
“Get somebody who can really stand up, who can really answer questions from the senator judges,” he told the defense.
His intervention followed questions from Senator-judges Raffy Tulfo and Joel Villanueva about the scope of Dela Fuente’s testimony and his preparation to address the prosecution’s financial findings.
“Is he a super witness, omni-witness?” Tulfo asked after defense lawyer Mark Vinluan’s direct examination moved into constitutional provisions on impeachment and voting rights.
Dela Fuente had been presented to discuss fundamental legal concepts under the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) and related matters.
Tulfo questioned whether the constitutional subjects fell within his expertise.
“Parang binobola lang tayo nito (It seems we are being played here),” (Raffy) Tulfo said.
Impeachment Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero said the court would interpret basic legal provisions itself.
He said Dela Fuente had not been presented or qualified as a constitutional expert and directed Vinluan to wind up the constitutional questions or move to his next point.
Meanwhile, Villanueva acknowledged the witness’ role in explaining anti-money laundering law and banking practices, underscoring that binding legal conclusions and decisions on criminal liability belonged to the proper authorities.
“Hindi po siya ang DOJ, hindi po siya ang Ombudsman (He is not the DOJ, he is not the Ombudsman),” he said.
Villanueva said he had no objection if the witness’ purpose was to refute the prosecution’s financial expert, lawyer Alexander Cabrera.
When he asked whether the defense had given Dela Fuente a copy of Cabrera’s forensic report, Vinluan said no.
Vinluan said the defense was showing portions of the report in court and seeking general comments.
He said the defense wanted to proceed in open court without prior correspondence with the subpoenaed witness.
Dela Fuente had earlier said he had not read the report entirely.
Raffy Tulfo said the witness should have received the documents beforehand to study the findings and conduct research before offering a rebuttal.
“Maybe ang problema sa defense, sobrang bilib sila sa’yo (Maybe the problem with the defense is that they think too highly of you),” he said.
Senator-judge Risa Hontiveros also asked whether Dela Fuente had reviewed the subpoenaed records Cabrera used.
The witness said he had not, citing their confidentiality and his lack of authority to examine them.
“So, ibig sabihin, with all due respect po, sa ngayon, wala po kayo sa solid na posisyon na suriin yung kalidad or katotohanan or solidong basehan kahit po sa general principles nung forensic report na iyon ni Atty. Cabrera (That means, with all due respect, as of right now, you are not in a solid position to examine the quality, truthfulness, or solid basis—even on general principles—of that forensic report by Atty. Cabrera)?” Hontiveros asked.
Dela Fuente maintained he had a basis to answer by referring to the law shown on screen. (PNA)
______
DEFENSE WITNESS. Lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente testifies as a defense witness during the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte on Thursday (Nov. 19, 2026). Several senator-judges questioned how Dela Fuente would challenge a forensic report that the defense had not supplied him.