
(Screenshot from Senate livestream)
MANILA – The Senate impeachment court on Friday issued a show cause order against Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesperson, lawyer Paolo Panelo, following his repeated public criticisms of senator-judges, including allegations of bias and improper conduct during the impeachment trial.
Presiding Officer Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero approved a motion filed by Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo, directing Panelo to explain his remarks questioning the impartiality of several members of the impeachment court.
The order was issued without objection from the senator-judges.
Panelo earlier accused Senators Risa Hontiveros, Francis Pangilinan and Raffy Tulfo of displaying bias while questioning defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a former official of the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC).
He argued that challenging a witness’s credibility should be the responsibility of the prosecution and urged Escudero to remind senator-judges to exercise restraint and maintain impartiality.
Panelo also accused the prosecution on Thursday of attempting to influence public opinion against Duterte.
During Friday’s proceedings, Tulfo questioned why Panelo, who is not a party to the impeachment case, was publicly attacking the credibility of senator-judges while serving as the vice president’s spokesperson.
“Can we do something about this, Mr. Presiding Officer? Because, I mean, he’s not party to this case. Pero siya po ang tagapagsalita ng bise presidente,” Tulfo said.
“I mean, you are the spokesperson of the vice president now on trial here, and then magkokomento ka against sa mga senator-judges, the impeachment court.”
Tulfo maintained that Panelo’s statements appeared to undermine respect for the impeachment tribunal.
“Eh para namang wala pong respeto sa impeachment court, Mr. Presiding Officer,” he added.
Responding to Tulfo, Escudero clarified that Rule 18, which governs public comments on pending proceedings under the impeachment court’s sub judice rule, does not directly apply to Panelo.
He explained that Panelo is neither a lawyer of record, a witness nor a party to the impeachment proceedings.
However, Escudero said the impeachment court could still exercise its authority under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court, which governs contempt proceedings and applies suppletorily to the trial.
“However, given the suppletory application of the Rules of Court, particularly Rule 71 on contempt, he may be covered or under the authority of this court,” Escudero said.
Following the clarification, Tulfo formally moved for the issuance of a show cause order requiring Panelo to explain his statements.
“And I therefore file a motion to issue a show cause order for the spokesperson of the vice president,” Tulfo said.
Escudero immediately granted the motion after no senator-judge raised an objection.
“Upon motion, there being no objection, the motion is hereby approved,” Escudero ruled.
He subsequently directed the clerk of court to issue the order against Panelo.
The show cause order requires Panelo to explain his conduct before the tribunal determines whether further action is warranted. It does not constitute a finding of contempt.
Panelo’s statements also differed from the position expressed Thursday by defense panel spokesperson Michael Poa, who acknowledged the authority of senator-judges to ask questions and express their views during the proceedings.
The controversy unfolded as Duterte’s defense continued presenting evidence in response to allegations involving at least Php 817.87 million in unexplained wealth under Article II of the impeachment complaint.
The Senate impeachment court has yet to determine the merits of the allegations against the vice president.