Marcos warns against false equivalence in SCS maritime disputes

President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr. has cautioned the international community against false equivalence in maritime disputes, asserting that not all claims in the South China Sea are legitimate and equal. He called for the rejection of disinformation and unilateral actions that violate international law.

In a foreign policy speech delivered at the Observer Research Foundation in New Delhi on Wednesday, Marcos stated that powerful nations are undermining the global order by disregarding international law, eroding rules-based norms, and masking aggressive actions under the guise of geopolitics.

“The complex issue of competing claims in the South China Sea has, for years, been unfortunately and simplistically reduced to ‘the South China Sea disputes,’ as if claims were all equal. They are not,” Marcos emphasized. He stressed that the assertions of littoral states must conform to international law, particularly the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) and definitive, binding interpretations such as the 2016 Arbitral Award.

Marcos warned against allowing “inaccurate narratives” to dominate discussions and obscure illegal actions, asserting that countries like the Philippines and India must take a more active role in upholding, defending, and preserving the rules-based order.

India: A Responsible Major Power

The President praised India as a “responsible major power,” highlighting its compliance with international tribunal rulings on maritime disputes, contrasting this with China’s rejection of the 2016 arbitral ruling that invalidated its expansive claims over the South China Sea. “For a country with rapidly growing power and influence, India has submitted to the judgment of international tribunals on matters concerning maritime disputes—a model for how a responsible major power and a good neighbor should behave,” he stated.

Marcos noted that global governance is under significant pressure from strategic competition, coercive actions, and institutional fatigue. He warned that some founding defenders of the post-war order have “turned inward,” while others exploit this shift to “cloak opaque claims with a semblance of legitimacy.” He cautioned that such narratives can obscure the international community’s judgment and that some powers are seeking to take advantage of this shift.

These remarks come amid heightened tensions in the West Philippine Sea, where Philippine and Chinese vessels have clashed in multiple confrontations, with Manila accusing Beijing of illegal incursions and dangerous maneuvers near Philippine-held features.

Strategic Partnership with India

Marcos’ speech concluded the New Delhi leg of his state visit, during which the Philippines and India formally elevated their ties to a Strategic Partnership—only the fifth such accord Manila has entered into, following similar arrangements with Japan, Australia, Vietnam, and South Korea. He noted that India possesses the “strategic trust, common cause, and responsible behavior” that the Philippines seeks in deepening ties, describing the partnership as a product of “great deliberation” rather than a mere diplomatic trend.

“India has emerged as one of the countries with which the Philippines finds these sterling qualities,” he said. “Our strategic partnership reflects the growing convergence of our long-term interests in the context of the historic shifts that will inform the ebb and flow of this century.”

Democracy, Multilateralism, and Middle Power Leadership

Marcos called for reforms in global institutions and more assertive leadership by emerging middle powers to safeguard multilateralism from paralysis. “Some so-called ‘major countries’ exert undue influence. We must ensure meaningful reforms in the United Nations and the Security Council itself—towards inclusivity, equity, and justice,” he stated.

He urged democracies to collaborate in protecting the global commons and upholding laws, even amid intensifying great power competition. “The world and our region must be able to seize maximum gains from the transformative power of advanced technologies, while paying due attention to their disruptive potential,” he said. “We are not invested in rivalry—we are invested in stability.”

On Thursday, the President is set to travel to Bengaluru, India’s tech hub, to deepen economic engagement and meet with industry leaders.

Leave a Reply