Prosecutors at the International Criminal Court (ICC) have rejected the defense team’s request to disqualify two judges from handling the jurisdictional challenge in the case of former President Rodrigo Duterte.
Duterte’s lead counsel, Nicholas Kaufman, earlier asked the ICC to remove Judges Reine Adélaïde Sophie Alapini-Gansou and María del Socorro Flores Liera from ruling on the matter. He argued that since both judges previously authorized the court’s investigation, it was unlikely they could remain impartial.
However, in a response dated May 22, Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang outlined four key reasons for denying the request:
- A strong standard must be met to question a judge’s impartiality.
- Judges commonly decide on the same or similar legal issues in different phases.
- The Rome Statute allows for multiple rulings on jurisdiction.
- The judges’ earlier rulings were only preliminary and do not indicate bias.
“The defense request should be rejected because it fails to call into question the presumption of impartiality attached to the Judges. Contrary to the Defense’s position, the Judges have not ‘already predetermined the outcome of the jurisdictional dispute in [the Prosecution’s] favor,’” the prosecution said.
It added, “[T]he Judges’ prior ruling does not amount to any perceived bias in this case, and any conclusion to the contrary would result in the untenable situation where a judge may be barred from issuing decisions on the same legal issue more than once.”
Duterte, 80, is currently in ICC custody in The Hague, Netherlands, where he faces charges of crimes against humanity in connection with his administration’s deadly war on drugs. His confirmation of charges hearing is set for September.