ICC Judges reject Duterte’s disqualification motion, proceed with Jurisdictional Challenge

The International Criminal Court (ICC) Plenary of Judges has found no bias or lack of impartiality in two judges of the Pre-Trial Chamber who are overseeing former Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte’s jurisdictional challenge. The judges dismissed Duterte’s motion to disqualify Judges Reine Adélaïde Sophia Alapini-Gansou and María del Socorro Flores Liera on June 9, with the full reasoning released on July 3.

The Plenary emphasized the seriousness of disqualifying a judge, noting that the defense team must provide evidence to support claims of bias. The judges ruled that Alapini-Gansou and Liera have been performing their legal functions in accordance with the Rome Statute, leading to a unanimous decision to reject the disqualification case.

Duterte’s defense argued that the judges had previously ruled on the same issue when they ordered the investigation into the “Situation in the Republic of the Philippines” on September 15, 2021. The judges had determined that the ICC retained jurisdiction over alleged crimes committed in the Philippines while it was a State Party, despite the country’s withdrawal from the court in March 2019.

On March 7, 2025, Pre-Trial Chamber I issued a warrant for Duterte’s arrest, which occurred on March 11. His first appearance was scheduled for March 12, with a confirmation of charges hearing set for September 23. According to the Rome Statute, jurisdiction challenges can be made once before the same Pre-Trial Chamber before a trial begins.

The plenary reiterated that Pre-Trial Chambers can authorize investigations if there is a reasonable basis for jurisdiction. With no judges removed from the proceedings, the Pre-Trial Chamber will now focus on the legal merits of Duterte’s jurisdictional challenge submitted on May 1.

Additionally, a decision is pending on Duterte’s “Urgent Request for Interim Release,” filed on June 12. The defense argues that the 80-year-old former president is neither a flight risk nor a threat to victims. However, the Prosecution contends that Duterte poses a threat due to his continued denial of the ICC’s authority and his narrative of being “kidnapped.”

The defense has requested to respond to the Prosecution regarding alleged changes in third countries related to the interim release. They also plan to present findings from the Philippine Senate’s Committee on Foreign Relations to support their claim that Duterte’s arrest was illegal. Meanwhile, the Prosecution has submitted its eleventh batch of evidence as part of the ongoing disclosure process ordered by Pre-Trial Chamber I.

Leave a Reply