Former Supreme Court Associate Justice Adolf Azcuna, who played a key role in drafting the accountability provisions for public officers in the 1987 Constitution, has stated that the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte can proceed in the 20th Congress if the Senate initiates it before adjourning on June 13.
In a Facebook post, Azcuna explained that the articles of impeachment must be read in the Senate and served to the vice president to activate the Senate’s jurisdiction over the case. Once this occurs, the trial can continue into the 20th Congress, which is set to convene in July.
Senate Majority Leader Francis Tolentino has contended that the impeachment case would be dismissed if the 19th Congress adjourns without addressing it. However, Azcuna, who drafted Article XI of the Constitution, argued that an impeachment trial is a constituent power and does not fall under the rule that unfinished business lapses with the outgoing Congress. He stated, “The Constitution says the opposite—that the trial must ‘proceed’, meaning it must continue until it is finished.”
He emphasized that it cannot proceed if it is allowed to lapse, asserting, “Since it must proceed, it follows that it does not lapse.” Azcuna warned that dismissing the case would constitute a grave violation of Article XI, which requires the Senate to “forthwith” convene an impeachment court as soon as a complaint signed by at least a third of the House members is filed. He clarified that “forthwith” means “immediately and without unreasonable delay,” or in Filipino, “agad-agad.”
Several draft resolutions have reportedly been proposed to seek the dismissal of the trial due to time constraints, with Senator Ronald “Bato” Dela Rosa admitting to initiating one of the drafts. The House impeached Duterte in February of this year, but the Senate did not act on the complaint, citing its break and the fact that the articles of impeachment had not been reported in plenary.
The Senate was scheduled to have the articles of impeachment read on June 2, but Senate President Francis “Chiz” Escudero postponed that to June 11, the last session before the Senate adjourns.
Azcuna noted that if dismissal resolutions are filed and adopted by the Senate, the dismissal of the impeachment case could still be reversed by the 20th Congress or by the Supreme Court. However, he specified that only senators who voted with the majority could request reconsideration. This means that if the majority of the plenary opts to dismiss the trial, a senator who opposes the dismissal and remains in the 20th Congress must vote with the majority to have a chance to file a motion for reconsideration when the next Congress convenes on July 28.