Experts say SC ruling on Duterte impeachment inconsistent

Official seal of the Supreme Court of the Republic of the Philippines featuring the national colors of blue, red, and yellow, along with a sun and scales of justice.

Former Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio on Thursday described this year’s Supreme Court resolution on the impeachment of Vice President Sara Duterte as “very inconsistent” compared with its July 2025 decision on the same matter.

Carpio made the remark during a forum on impeachment at the University of the Philippines Diliman, noting differences in the Court’s stance on required votes at the plenary level and constitutional issues.

He said the court has since “walked back” additional requirements, particularly the endorsement of a complaint by one-third of House members, which had previously been questioned.

UP College of Law Dean Gwen Grecia De Vera said certain aspects of the Supreme Court’s handling of the impeachment appear “problematic” and seem to depart from the Constitutional Commission’s records that favor a more liberal approach.

Also speaking at the forum were 1986 Constitutional Commission member and retired Associate Justice Adolfo Azcuna, and former Far Eastern University Institute of Law dean Mel Sta. Maria, who joined discussions on the future of impeachment in the Philippines.

The Supreme Court last month reaffirmed its ruling that the articles of impeachment against Duterte were unconstitutional and that the Senate lacked jurisdiction over the proceedings.

The decision was issued en banc on January 28, when the Court unanimously denied a motion for reconsideration filed by the House of Representatives.

Legal experts emphasized that the ruling underscores the importance of clarity and consistency in interpreting constitutional provisions on impeachment to ensure public trust in the process.

Leave a Reply