
Third day of the impeachment trial against VP Sara Duterte. The defense led by Atty. Carlo Narvasa started to cross-examine the first witness of prosecution, NBI Senior Agent John Mark Calilung. Screengrab from Senate of the Philippines/YouTube. July 8, 2026.
Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team on Wednesday argued that her alleged threats against President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., First Lady Liza Araneta-Marcos and former Speaker Martin Romualdez did not constitute a high crime that could justify her removal from office.
During the third day of Duterte’s impeachment trial, defense lawyers used their cross-examination of National Bureau of Investigation senior agent John Mark Calilung to challenge the prosecution’s theory under Article IV of the impeachment complaint.
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan said the House prosecution panel had not presented competent proof that Duterte had hired or contracted an assassin to carry out a plot against the Marcos couple and Romualdez.
He argued that the video recordings presented by prosecutors merely showed that Duterte made the statements, but did not prove that an actual assassination plot existed.
The defense maintained that Duterte’s remarks should be weighed against the circumstances surrounding her family and office at the time, including alleged surveillance, security concerns and the detention of her chief of staff, Zuleika Lopez, during a House inquiry.
Defense lawyer Carlo Narvasa said Duterte’s statements were made after Lopez was cited in contempt and faced transfer to the Correctional Institution for Women, an incident the defense described as part of broader pressure against the Vice President and her staff.
The defense also questioned the NBI’s investigation, noting that Marcos, Araneta-Marcos and Romualdez did not personally file sworn complaints or appear before the bureau. Calilung said the NBI acted on its own authority and that his role was limited to authenticating the videos.
Prosecutors rejected the defense’s position and maintained that Calilung’s testimony remained intact. They said the witness had established the authenticity of Duterte’s Nov. 23, 2024 video, while the broader issue of whether the remarks amounted to an impeachable offense would be for the Senate impeachment court to decide.