
The Department of Tourism (DOT) has doubled down on its call for accountability and transparency following HelloSafe’s retraction of a widely criticized report that wrongly branded the Philippines as one of the world’s least safe travel destinations.
In a formal apology dated July 15, HelloSafe admitted to publishing a flawed travel safety index that sparked international concern and damage to the country’s reputation. The financial comparison site suspended the report last June 20, citing the need for a full audit of its methodology and data sources. The company also extended its “sincere regrets” for the negative impact of the publication and affirmed its “deep respect for the Philippines and its people.”
Tourism Secretary Christina Garcia Frasco welcomed the apology—but made it clear that the damage had been done.
“Disseminating false and misleading information under the guise of a safety index caused unwarranted alarm and inflicted harm on our nation’s image,” said Frasco in a letter addressed to HelloSafe founder Antoine Fruchard. “As we move forward with the National Tourism Development Plan 2023–2028, we expect the Philippines to be represented fairly, truthfully, and with the dignity that our people and destinations deserve.”
Frasco emphasized that although HelloSafe has since removed the report, earlier versions—including damaging headlines—remain live on several global platforms. “The reputational damage persists,” she said. “The original content, which mischaracterized the Philippines, has already been widely circulated and continues to influence public perception.”
The DOT chief underscored the need for greater scrutiny in releasing global reports that shape how countries are viewed on the world stage.
“Rankings like these carry real-world consequences. Misleading studies can undermine years of hard work by the government and private sector in promoting the Philippines as a safe and world-class tourism destination,” she said.
Tourism is a key driver of the Philippine economy, accounting for 8.9 percent of GDP and providing jobs to 6.75 million Filipinos in 2024, based on data from the Philippine Tourism Satellite Accounts (PTSA).
The controversy began last month when HelloSafe released a travel safety index that ranked the Philippines among the least safe destinations globally. The report drew immediate backlash from the tourism sector, with critics pointing out its lack of transparency, use of unverifiable data, and suspiciously recycled safety scores across different countries.
In a June 19 social media post, Secretary Frasco publicly questioned the credibility of the index, calling attention to its vague methodology and the absence of credible sourcing.
Tourism groups including the Philippine Hotel Owners Association (PHOA), Pacific Asia Travel Association (PATA), Philippine IATA Agents Travel Association (PIATA), Philippine Travel Agencies Association (PTAA), and the Philippine Tour Operators Association (PHILTOA) also condemned the report, calling it “misleading” and damaging to the industry.
While the DOT acknowledges HelloSafe’s decision to take down the report, it says the lesson must not be forgotten.
“Content publishers must recognize the power they wield,” Frasco said. “With that power comes the responsibility to ensure accuracy, fairness, and accountability—especially when their work impacts nations and livelihoods.”