
By Marita Moaje
MANILA – The Department of Migrant Workers (DMW) on Monday welcomed a Supreme Court ruling on a Filipino seafarer’s disability claim, noting that it will help guide the handling of similar cases involving illnesses contracted at sea, including those not listed as occupational diseases.
In a news release,Migrant Workers Secretary Hans Leo Cacdac said the SC en banc decision in the RCCL Crew Management Inc. and Royal Caribbean Cruise Ltd. vs. Jonathan Ian H. Ponio case (G.R. No. 263434) clarifies the rights and medical obligations of seafarers and their employers.
The case involved galley steward Jonathan Ian Ponio, who passed his pre-employment medical examination with normal hearing prior to working as a galley steward.
While handling galley duties, cleaning and sanitizing workspaces, he contracted an infection on his right ear and was medically repatriated on Oct. 30, 2017, following a diagnosis of moderate to severe conductive hearing loss.
His employers, however, failed to give him a written copy of the final medical assessment.
Under the 2010 Philippine Overseas Employment Administration – Standard Employment Contract (POEA-SEC), an illness not listed as an occupational disease is presumed work-related and compensable if there is substantial evidence that it developed during the seafarer’s employment.
Employers can challenge the claim by presenting medical evidence that the illness was not caused by the work or existed before deployment, and if they successfully do so, the seafarer must provide evidence linking the illness to the job.
The Court also clarified that seafarers must undergo a medical examination within three working days after repatriation and attend regular checkups, and that employers must give them a written copy of the final medical assessment within 120 or 240 days.
Failure to provide the assessment means the disability is considered total and permanent by law.
The Supreme Court ordered RCCL Crew Management Inc. and Royal Caribbean Cruise Ltd. to pay Ponio USD95,000 in permanent total disability benefits under his Collective Bargaining Agreement, plus 10 percent attorney’s fees and 6 percent annual legal interest.
The DMW said the decision reinforces the need for manning agencies, foreign principals and seafarers to comply with their obligations under the POEA-SEC, consistent with Republic Act 12021, or the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.
“The decision strengthens fairness, transparency, and predictability in maritime employment relations, in line with Republic Act No. 12021,” Cacdac said.
He also reminded licensed manning agencies, foreign principals and seafarers to “strictly observe their respective medical and reporting obligations.”
Seafarers needing legal or welfare assistance may contact the DMW Office of the Assistant Secretary for Seabased OFW Concerns at seabased.asec@dmw.gov.ph. (PNA)