Comelec hits pause on proclamation of two winning party-lists, pending case resolutions

The Commission on Elections (Comelec) suspended the proclamation of two party-list groups pending the resolution of their pending cases, it was learned Monday.

Comelec chair George Garcia shared the development in a press briefing, just hours before this afternoon’s proclamation of the other winning party-list groups.

“Meron po tayong dalawang party-list na hindi mapoproklama,” he said.

“Sinuspend po ng National Board of Canvassers and proclamation nila dahil sa pending cases nila,” he explained.

“Ito po’y base sa determination mismo ng National Board of Canvassers at kasama na rin yung mismong division na may hawak ng mga kaso na yan,” Garcia added.

Although he did not give the name of the party-list, but gave a clue.

“Yung isa may tatlong seat, yung isa may isang seat.”

Akbayan, Duterte Youth, and Tingog each secured three seats in the midterm party-list elections.

“Considering the serious allegations raised in the petitions filed against these party-lists, then the national board decided to suspend their proclamation. They won but suspended ang kanilang proclamation,” Garcia explained.

Garcia pledged that the commission will settle the outstanding cases by June 30 at the latest.

“Nanalo po sila, kasama po sila. Yung isa po ay may tatlong seats, yung isa po ay may isang seat. Kung sakali po na sila ay hindi maproklama mamaya, hindi nangangahulugan na hindi sila maproklama sa mga susunod,” he said.

The National Board of Canvassers (NBOC) clarified that only 63 party-list seats will be filled, not the 64 initially contested during the vote canvassing.

“Ito ay nagrerepresenta ng tinatawag natin na 20% ng total composition ng House of Representatives, dapat po ang computation diyan ay 63.5, kaya lang wala naman pong point 5 na tao kung kaya hindi po tayo puwedeng mag-round off, considering fraction na yun kaya nagdesisyon ang board na ito ay ibase lamang sa 63,” said Garcia.

“Sa 63 na yan ay meron tayo na 3 partylist na entitled sa tig-ta-tatlo, meron din po tatlo na entitled sa tig-da-dalawa,” he added.

Garcia explained that the NBOC’s seat calculation followed the formula established by the Supreme Court in the Banat vs. Comelec ruling.

“Merong isang partylist na nakakuha ng 0.99 pero hindi nai-consider 0.99 na ‘yun, sapagkat ang contention po ng party-list na ‘yun ay dapat daw po ‘yung 0.99 ay entitled pa sa isa,” he said.

“So kung dalawa sila dapat daw po ay may isa pa. Pero siyempre ang contention po ng national board, base sa decision ng Korte Suprema ang 0.99 ay hindi one. At dahil hindi po ‘yun one ay hindi entitled sa pangatlo na seat,” he added.

Garcia noted that, under the NBOC’s final tabulation, the top three party-list organizations will each be allotted three seats in Congress. Those placing fourth, fifth, and sixth will receive two seats apiece, while all remaining qualifying groups will be assigned one seat each.

He added that invitations have already been dispatched to the 52 party-list organizations cleared for proclamation.

Meanwhile, the NBOC has forwarded its resolution to the two party-list groups whose proclamations remain on hold due to unresolved cases.

Leave a Reply