A step toward accountability

Portrait of a man with glasses smiling, overlayed with text 'IT SAYS HERE' and the name 'DIEGO CAGAHASTIAN', set against a crumpled paper background.

“It is health that is real wealth and not pieces of gold and silver.” — Mahatma Gandhi

—o0o—

Lawyer and human rights advocate Lorenzo “Erin” Tañada III welcomed the Professional Regulatory Commission (PRC) Board of Medicine’s decision to proceed with the formal investigation of the administrative case against Bell-Kenz Pharma Inc. officers Dr. Luis Raymond Go and Dr. Viannely Berwyn Flores for alleged dishonorable and unprofessional conduct.

In a 12-page resolution, the PRC Board of Medicine denied Dr. Flores’ motion to dismiss and likewise rejected all reliefs sought by Dr. Go in his omnibus motion. The Board further ordered both respondents to file their verified answers or counter-affidavits within 10 days from receipt of the resolution.

The resolution of the Board of Medicine dated Nov. 26, 2025 ruled on Administrative Case No. 3513 and was released by Atty. Carla Evangeline Ujano, chief of the hearing and investigation division. It was signed by Efren Laxamana, chairperson, and members Joanna Remo, Martha Nucum, Prudencio Sta. Lucia Jr. and Policarpio Jovez Jr., while Joselito Chavez inhibited.

Tañada, who filed the administrative complaint in July, said the PRC’s ruling affirms the gravity of the allegations involving the doctors’ roles in Bell-Kenz’s purported multi-level marketing (MLM) scheme—an issue that has raised urgent concerns over ethics, conflict of interest, and patient welfare within the medical profession.

“This is a step toward making doctors accountable,” Tañada said. “We have asserted that the alleged Bell-Kenz scheme goes beyond corporate marketing—its true harm lies in how it compromises the independence and integrity of medical judgment. The PRC Board’s decision finally recognizes that these allegations must be fully investigated.”

The Board emphasized in its resolution that the complaint sufficiently alleges violations of the Code of Ethics of the Medical Profession, particularly the charge that both physicians participated in unethical and dishonorable conduct. It further stressed that while related allegations may be subject to separate actions before other agencies, the PRC can independently pursue its mandate to ensure ethical medical practice.

Tañada noted that this aligns with his position that a doctor’s involvement in an MLM scheme raises red flags that cannot be ignored when the medical profession is expressly bound by strict ethical rules prohibiting conflicts of interest.

“The PRC made it clear: ethical violations stand on their own,” he said. “You cannot hide behind technicalities when the core issue is whether doctors used their profession—and public trust—for commercial gain. That is precisely why this case must move forward.”

The Board also rejected claims that the complaint lacked sufficient evidence, noting that it is supported by transcripts of the doctors’ own sworn testimonies during last year’s Senate inquiry, a certified true copy of which was submitted by the complainant. These admissions, the Board said, formed the core factual basis of the complaint.

Also, the PRC dismissed arguments questioning Tañada’s legal standing to file the case. The Board held that administrative complaints against licensed professionals involve public interest and may be initiated by parties acting to defend the integrity of the medical profession and protect Filipino patients.

For Tañada, this affirmation is critical to ensuring that regulatory bodies are not hamstrung by overly technical interpretations of who may call out unethical practices. “If unethical conduct affects the public, then the public—through citizens, advocates, or lawyers like myself—must have the right to demand accountability,” he said.

He added that the PRC’s ruling reiterates that the Bell-Kenz model purportedly blurred professional boundaries by allegedly incentivizing doctors through commissions, downlines, and product-based earnings—arrangements that have no place in a profession built on patient trust.

With the denial of all motions and objections, the case will now proceed to the formal investigation stage, where both doctors must respond to the accusations under oath.

“Formal investigation is where the truth will finally be established,” Tañada said. “The public deserves clarity. Doctors deserve a profession untainted by commercial manipulation. And patients deserve medical care that is free from financial influence.”

Tañada emphasized the case is not about targeting individuals but about protecting the credibility of the medical profession and preventing similar schemes from taking root in the healthcare system.

“We are here to defend the integrity of a profession that Filipinos depend on for their health and safety. If we do not act now, more patients may unknowingly suffer from medical advice influenced not by science, but by sales commissions,” he added.

Tañada also urged the public and medical community to view the PRC’s move as an institutional affirmation that ethical breaches will not be tolerated. “This is accountability in action,” he said. “And accountability is the foundation of trust—trust in our doctors, trust in our public institutions, and trust in the healthcare system.”

The formal investigation will commence upon filing of the respondents’ verified answers. Should they fail to comply, the PRC warned that they may be declared in default.

“We filed this case because we believe the medical profession must stay true to its oath. The PRC Board of Medicine’s resolution is a step forward—and we will continue pushing until full accountability is achieved,” Tañada said.

This development is significant because the formal investigation will afford the two doctors the opportunity to defend themselves from the accusations hurled at them by Tañada, who authored the country’s first Universal Health Care (UHC) bill during his congressional stint.

The issue should not end with the final resolution of this case, which the former congressman is pursuing to its logical end, but the probe should be taken up by other government agencies such as the Department of Health and the Department of Trade and Industry, if they are interested in finding more space for reforms in the health sector.

Leave a Reply